Despite the complaints of the two Election Commissioners regarding the conduct of a high-ranking officer in the Election Commission, who had exceeded his constitutional powers, the Cabinet Secretary rejected all allegations of interference, considering them inappropriate.
In response to the two Commissioners, he said that whatever they do will be treated as interference and inappropriate behavior in constitutional functions.
His response was in the light of a letter complaining, which was written by Election Commissioners Dr. Sukhvir Singh Sandhu and Dr. Vivek Joshi on 29 July.
The above-mentioned information regarding the letters exchanged between the two Election Commissioners and the Cabinet Secretary can be obtained through documents issued by the Cabinet Secretariat under the Right to Information (RTI).
It states that the Cabinet Secretary, in his letter to both Election Commissioners, clarified that "although Manish Garg was appointed by the Appointments Committee of the Cabinet (ACC), he is now an officer of the Election Commission. As such, his work and conduct should be governed and monitored in accordance with the rules and guidelines of the Election Commission of India."
It also states that "since both Election Commissioners have made this complaint in their personal capacity, it should be taken seriously, but it cannot be considered an official communication from the Election Commission."
This information has been revealed in an RTI request by activist and retired Commodore Lokesh K. Batra. Letters from both Election Commissioners and a letter from the Cabinet Secretary have also been shared. The documents revealed clearly indicate that the Cabinet Secretary took cognizance of the complaint from both Election Commissioners but declined to intervene. He also shared this information with the Chief Election Commissioner's Principal Private Secretary (PPS).
It is noteworthy that both Election Commissioners wrote a complaint letter to Cabinet Secretary T.V. Somanathan on July 29th. They complained about the workload of Manish Garg, a senior ISS and Deputy Election Commissioner posted in the Election Commission. They also described how he had distributed workloads without the Election Commissioners' consent, despite their directives.
This was done while they were in additional charge, while the authorized officer was on leave, a clear violation of civil service rules. However, after the disclosure of the letter to the Cabinet Secretary, questions are being raised about the two Election Commissioners.
Following the controversy surrounding the letter written by the two Election Commissioners to the Cabinet Secretary, the Election Commission issued a statement on September 26th clarifying that the workload allocation order issued by the concerned officer was not implemented despite the Commissioners' directives.
It also clarified that the letter sent by Sandhu and Joshi to the Cabinet Secretary was not related to any policy matter or the IT department, but was related to an officer on deputation to the Commission.